Eugene Drucker, First Violin of the Emersons, writes that “rarely has mental instability created such a rich aesthetic harvest” as in the music of Robert Schumann, especially in the three string quartets, composed in a matter of weeks during 1842. While I agree with this observation, I’ve always suspected that the conjecture that these works convey incipient symptoms of bi-polarity is more an example of what psychiatrists term “narcissistic projection” – people foisting or “reading” their own neuroses onto others – than genuine analysis or insight.

album artwork

That said, they are suffused with emotional volatility and undeniably intermittently febrile passages. Furthermore, Jed Distler, a reviewer whom I always admire, especially for his acerbic wit, wrote that the First Quartet (A Minor) is...

Access our paywalled content and archive of magazines, regular news and features for the limited offer of $3 per month. Support independent journalism.

Subscribe now or log in to continue reading.